01.09.2026
Paid Media

A holiday rental agency relaunches its Google Ads campaigns at the end of December to prepare for the summer season, with one Search campaign per destination and a Performance Max campaign.

An independent holiday rental agency, specialising in premium villas in several Southern European destinations, relaunches its Google Ads account at the end of December to prepare for the summer season. The account had a history of old campaigns, all stopped for several years. Two campaigns resume acquisition: a Search campaign organised by destination and a single Performance Max campaign. Both run in parallel for six months, until the end of June, on a stable monthly budget.
The budget split remained stable over the whole period: 62% for Performance Max, 38% for Search. The split of results is anything but proportional. Performance Max generated 95% of the account's bookings and 77% of total value. Performance Max's ROAS came out at x50.6, compared with x24.7 for Search, a return on ad spend twice as high.
The cost per booking on Search ended up 11.1 times higher than on Performance Max, with a click-through rate 5.5 times lower and a cost per click twice as high. On this account, every euro placed in Performance Max returned twice as much as a euro placed in Search.
The gap can be seen month by month. Performance Max starts slowly in January and then grows almost without interruption until June, with a booking volume that holds up over time despite stable monthly spending. Search follows the opposite trajectory: a decent start in January and February, then a collapse from March, with two consecutive months without a single booking in the middle of the campaign, while its budget stays the same. A Search campaign that no longer converts but keeps consuming the same budget is a signal to cut before the end of the planned period, not after.
The second lesson is internal to the Search campaign itself. The account is structured by destination, and the budget split between destinations does not follow performance. The main destination receives 81.6% of the Search budget for a conversion rate of 0.44%, while the secondary destination, which receives only 14.7% of the budget, converts 2.5 times better and has a cost per booking 2.6 times lower. The third destination, with 3.8% of the Search budget, generated no bookings over the whole period. This internal imbalance explains part of Search's underperformance compared with Performance Max: the problem is not just the channel, it is also how the budget is split between destinations within that channel.
This case does not say that Search should be abandoned in favour of an all-Performance-Max approach. A campaign per destination is still useful for covering precise queries that Performance Max does not target in the same way, and for keeping visibility on rising destinations. But a Search budget frozen for six months, with no allocation between destinations and no cuts on segments that no longer convert, ends up funding volume without results while Performance Max does the conversion work. The right way to read an account like this is not Search versus Performance Max, it is how quickly each campaign is corrected during the season.
ID Interactive, our agency based in Vannes, generated a ROAS of x50.6 on Performance Max (which delivered 95% of bookings and 77% of value) over six months for a premium holiday rental agency, by solving the problem of a Search budget poorly allocated between destinations and a lack of dynamic allocation on seasonal campaigns.
Related case studies: Google Ads in a niche market, the Google Ads and Meta Ads campaigns of a figurine e-commerce shop and measuring the real value of conversions in e-commerce.
Oui, dès que la campagne enchaîne plusieurs mois sans réservation à budget constant, le signal est suffisamment net pour ne pas attendre la fin de saison. Continuer à dépenser au même rythme sur une campagne qui ne convertit plus revient à financer du volume sans contrepartie, pendant qu'un autre canal du même compte affiche un ROAS deux fois supérieur.
Dans ce cas, l'écart se creuse dès le troisième mois et devient définitif à partir du quatrième. Performance Max a besoin d'un temps de montée en charge au démarrage, mais une fois cette phase passée, sa progression est restée constante sur toute la durée de la campagne, contrairement à Search qui a décroché après une phase initiale correcte.
Le signal le plus fiable est le croisement entre un budget mensuel stable et des conversions qui chutent : tant que la dépense suit la même courbe que les résultats, la campagne reste saine ; dès qu'elle continue à consommer le même budget sans plus rien produire, c'est qu'elle a décroché.
Non, et c'est justement l'erreur repérée ici : la destination qui recevait 81,6 % du budget convertissait deux fois et demie moins bien qu'une destination secondaire financée à 14,7 %. La répartition doit suivre le taux de conversion réel de chaque destination, pas son volume de recherches ou son poids historique dans le compte.